flag image
Aurora Health Care

Going paperless good, but not be-all



shadow
shadow
October 08, 2013 | 03:57 PM
Most people focus on announcements of new technology.

The release of the latest iPhone captures headlines and draws crowds of shoppers to wait, in vigil, around the nearest big-box electronics store.

Prompted by one such headline, I wrote a column earlier this year about the death of the typewriter. The ink was barely dry on that piece when I ran across an article on the internet announcing the death of the home stereo system.

For any reader under the age of, say 40, an explanation is in order. It wasn’t always possible for one to carry around their entire music collection in a shirt pocket.

A host of digital devices have “done in” the home stereo. This hardly qualifies as news to any parent who has started a heartfelt conversation with his or her teen, only to notice a blank look on their child’s face and wires protruding from their ears.

Still, I appreciated reading the stereo’s official obituary, because it got me thinking about technology and its tendency to focus our attention on the “trees” rather than the “forest.”

I remember back in the days of stereo that some guys would constantly tinker with their stereo systems in an effort to create the perfect sound.

It was often the case that the amount of music owned by these stereo aficionados was negatively correlated to the amount of time they spent fussing over their systems.

Building a stereo system is a fine hobby, but not necessarily the same thing as listening to good music.

ad
click to see advertisement
I was reminded of these old stereo buffs when I recently took a day to visit the annual Wisconsin Counties Association (WCA) convention.

It had been a number of years since I attended the event.

My last memory of the WCA was that its member-supervisors were fairly resistant to change.

You can imagine my surprise, then, at the most recent convention, to see the majority of supervisors toting iPads and computer tablets.

The main topic of conversation at most of the break-out sessions was the degree to which each county had achieved a “paperless” county board.

ad
click to see advertisement
WCA members bragged about the date when their county quit mailing out meeting agendas and supporting materials, and began providing the information to supervisors, exclusively in electronic form.

I didn’t have a calculator, but if I would have added up all of the savings in postage and photocopy costs that were alleged at the convention, Wisconsin counties could not only pay for all of those government-issued iPads, but make a big dent in the national debt, as well.

I’m all for streamlining our county’s agenda process. I’ve written on this subject before. We currently distribute six reams of paper to our supervisors, each month, to support the county board and standing committee meetings.

There is no question that we could save thousands of dollars by emailing committee agenda packets rather than delivering them in “hard-copy” form.

While it is important to save these thousands, it is more important that our supervisors are well-informed when they vote on the myriad of decisions that make up the county’s $148 million budget.

ad
click to see advertisement
A number of counties boasted that they made the transition “cold turkey;” get with the digital program or get off the board. I can’t endorse that approach quite yet.

There are a number of reasons, besides “foot dragging,” to explain the reluctance of some supervisors to jump on the bandwagon. Shifting the hassle of printing lengthy documents from the county’s high-speed digital copier to eleven ink-jet printers in supervisors’ homes is one of them.

People also learn in different ways; some can navigate and comprehend electronic documents far better than others. Our agendas and supporting materials, which are created to be read on 8½ x 11 inch typing paper, do little to help the cognitive process.

I am looking forward to working with our supervisors in the upcoming year to improve our agenda process. Before we venture too far into that “forest” however, we need to carefully choose our goal.

Computers, like home stereo systems, should be viewed as the means to an end, rather than the end itself.

By the same token, eliminating all “hard copy” documents won’t necessarily ensure a well-informed board.

The opinions expressed in this column are those of the author and not necessarily those of the Walworth County Board of Supervisors.

printPrint
emailEmail
CommentFeedback
shareShare
Comments ()
Walworth County Fair
Taste of Wisconsin
Regional News
LAKE GENEVA AREA REALTY