flag image

Traver Hotel future in limbo?



shadow
shadow
November 10, 2010 | 09:30 AM
It's not boarded up anymore and the Traver Hotel has undergone some improvements recently, but the old structure remains on the minds of Lake Geneva city officials.

On Monday night, City Attorney Dan Draper told the council members there are several options to look at regarding the future of the large white building, located at 323 Broad Street across from Horticultural Hall.

However, Draper would not go into specifics about what the city could do. He said he would provide the aldermen with the information by the end of the week.

"There are several statutes involved," he said. "Before embarking on a discussion, I would also like to talk to the building inspector."

Draper said there are options if the property is determined to be blighted and there also could be fines if it is determined to be a nuisance property.

"I would rather have an outline for you about what we can and can't do," Draper said.

But, Keith Venturi, the president of 323 Broad Street Property, which owns the building, said he did not know the status of the building would be discussed by the council Monday night. He did not attend the meeting.

Venturi said Tuesday the intention when the building was purchased was to "save the historic piece" and come up with a plan to reopen the building as a hotel.

Because of the economy and what Venturi called a lack of help from the city, nothing has happened with it in the past five to six years the company has owned it.

During the final week of October, the windows and doors of the building were boarded up by the city. According to officials from the Police and Fire departments, the building had become a safety concern. Among the items found in the building were beer cans, a dead raccoon and feces.

According to a memo from City Administrator Dennis Jordan, the property has been vacant for "almost a decade" and there have been "signs recently that unwanted persons have been inside the property." He said the property is "in disrepair" with dead animals found inside and the "toilets are not working, but have been used." Police photos taken before boarding up the building show there also is vandalism, gang graffiti and holes in the walls.

Since then, the boards have been removed and the windows repaired. Venturi said the building should not have been boarded up because the owners were not provided notice. He called it a "violation of property rights" and the city was "not authorized to be on the property." He said the owners were not cited and there are no structural problems with the building.

Venturi also said he has made a complaint to the city's Police Department because of the vandalism and graffiti. He blamed the department for not being able to stop the vandalism and apparent gang activity going on in the building.

Venturi also said he plans to add security lights and has asked city officials to provide alley lights. Venturi said he also intends to put an office for his family's construction company, VP Construction, in the building before next summer.

For some city officials, that may not be enough.

Alderman Don Tolar said Fire Department officials have stated firefighters will not go into the building if it is on fire.

Venturi said he had no knowledge of that statement and questioned why taxes are being paid on the property for public safety if the property is not going to be protected.

Draper said he planned to provide aldermen information about possible options so a discussion could occur about the building at a later date.

"I would like to give you an opinion before you go off on a tangent that may be improper given your guidelines," Draper said.

State Statutes cite when a building can be razed. The statute reads, "If a building is old, dilapidated or out of repair and consequently dangerous, unsafe, unsanitary or otherwise unfit for human habitation and unreasonable to repair, order the owner of the building to raze the building or, if the building can be made safe by reasonable repairs, order the owner to either make the building safe and sanitary or to raze the building, at the owner's option."

Statutes cite more specifics regarding how and why a building can be determined unsanitary or unfit for human habitation. It also states a building can be razed if it is determined a public nuisance. According to the statutes, public nuisance means "a building that, as a result of vandalism or any other reason, has deteriorated or is dilapidated or blighted to the extent that windows, doors or other openings, plumbing or heating fixtures, or facilities of appurtenances of the building are damaged, destroyed or removed so that the building offenses the aesthetic character of the immediate neighborhood and produces blight or deterioration."

Although there was no mention of razing the building Monday night, former alderman Tom Spellman said that's not the way to go, yet.

"It's a difficult building to deal with," Spellman said. "Nothing has been done with it in a long time, but that's not a reason to consider tearing it down. It's a little bit of an eyesore, but it's not terrible."

Spellman suggested the council do nothing right now with the building, but plan ahead.

"It's old, but it has character yet," he said. "Let's set up a committee to take a look at it."

This issue is expected to be on the agenda for the Nov. 22 meeting.

printPrint
emailEmail
CommentFeedback
shareShare
  1. report print email
    I would say....
    November 10, 2010 | 04:59 PM

    Get a grant for some repairs THEN turn the first floor into a roller rink/arcade and use the proceeds to make it into a swanky modern hotel suites for family friendly Lake Geneva STAYS... It has some real possibilities. HAVE A HAUNTED HOUSE NEXT YEAR to GET SOME INCOME GENERATION GOING, you can easily market that, and bring in 100,000s of dollars in one season. AN OLD HOTEL, seriously a big money maker.

    Chicago Style hot dog
    LG
  2. report print email
    Back to the Future
    November 10, 2010 | 05:21 PM

    Take our tourists back in Lake Geneva time by restoring this old hotel. Furnish it with furnishings of its time. Make it something from Lake Geneva's past. Here we are another opportunity to restore a part of our history, advertise it and make revenue to boot. Plus the museum could hold tours of the hotel as part of their experience as well. Let's not blow it again. We don't need another antique store, t-shirt shop or cotton candy store.

    W.H
  3. report print email
    hotel
    November 11, 2010 | 06:26 AM

    make it a hispanic center, their already using it the way it is. see people on roof all the time at night.

    jesus
    dullivin
  4. report print email
    I say
    November 11, 2010 | 09:21 AM

    make it a whorehouse

    Jesus, dullivin
  5. report print email
    What's the fascination with the old?
    November 11, 2010 | 10:48 AM

    If this building is in disrepair and is deemed to be unsafe, then one of two things should happen, completely redo it or tear it down. Personally, I find it an eyesore. Just because something's old doesn't mean it should be saved at all costs. 100 years ago, most places still had out houses, but I don't see a movement to restore them or feel the need to reminisce about the good old days of no indoor plumbing....

    Enough Already
    Lake Geneva
  6. report print email
    Here we go again
    November 11, 2010 | 07:47 PM

    Here we go again. the city council is going to get us into another law suit. Stop and think before we get into more trouble!

    Concerned Citizen
    Lake Geneva
  7. report print email
    RE: Enough Already
    November 11, 2010 | 08:03 PM

    I would like to see a comeback of outhouses. Means I wouldn't have a sewer and water bill. I would have a well for water. Bring back those days. Now as for retoring something old. Other countries go to extreme lengths to preserve their past. Here we do our best to get rid of it. Soon there will be nothing left to look back on from our past and I am talking about this nation as a whole. People go to Italy and France to enjoy outside cafes. We use to have them all over this country. Now people look at them as something new. I see nothing wrong at trying to preserve our past. The old theater downtown is another part of the past. I hope someone buys it and does something with it suited to the theater.

    W.H
  8. report print email
    W.H.
    November 12, 2010 | 02:16 PM

    I agree with you about the theater, it's still in decent condition and wouldn't take much to fix it up into something cool. The hotel, by most reports needs alot of work. Eventually, there comes a point where it just isn't worth it to "fix it up" and something new and usable would be better. Sometimes an eyesore is just an eyesore.

    Enough Already
    Lake Geneva
  9. report print email
    I say raise it!
    November 12, 2010 | 02:31 PM

    Put in a new 10 story hotel with a great view I know we don't need another failing eatery in this town.

    the pizza man
  10. report print email
    Don't make the same mistake, city . . .
    November 13, 2010 | 07:29 AM

    Like when the Frank Lloyd Wright hotel was torn down and a generic high-rise put in it's place. Let's treasure our past history . . . it's not all about the mansions. The Traver hotel could be a masterpiece and asset to the city.

    Ron in Phx, but heart in LG
    Phoenix
  11. report print email
    Parking
    November 15, 2010 | 01:54 PM

    Make it into a 3 or 4 story parking area. That's one thing that is realy neded downtown.

    Jack
    Lake Geneva
  12. report print email
    please
    November 17, 2010 | 11:36 AM

    Please lets not tear down another part of gl history! That place has great history, People come to lg for the history we are going to lose that if we keep tearing down our heritage! If you want modern go to a differant city lg is all about history and i feel the board has said enough about what people can do with what they own! Please save it

    julie
  13. report print email
    Traver Hotel
    November 22, 2010 | 03:41 PM

    About 10 years ago there were idea's to convert it to a hotel, a rooming house, and a halfway house. NONE were approved. The building has no parking #1..thus hotel and rooming house go away. 2. NO Elevator...how would anyone get upstairs with today's rulings on handicapped accessibility? 3. The building would need to have a sprinkler system if the upper floors are used...at WHAT cost would that be? 4. Architecturally, its not much more than a big box, with a failing rubber roof, a porch roof that goes OVER the public sidewalk...it's a blighted building, and will only continue to be broken into, or damaged. 5. Every bathroom would have to be upgraded to ADA standards, for disabled people...the costs would exceed any revenue that the building would generate. Sooner or later, a "camper" will set a fire to stay warm, and that will be the end of it...hope the church next door doesn't get destroyed in the process.
    The City needs to condemn the place, and at least use the lot for public parking, or let the owner of the property do that, and generate some type of revenue.

    Harry Johnson
    Lake Geneva
  14. report print email
    November 22, 2010 | 04:53 PM

    This building is an eyesore but until something is done with it my question is why the owner can let it get into such state of disrepair. Typical with everyone at the city. If it is not in THEIR own backyard they don't care. This needs to be brought up to code, fixed or tore down. This owner is responsible and no different from anyone else who owns property and is subject to any statutes.

    Newbie
    LG
  15. report print email
    December 21, 2010 | 06:30 PM

    I've always thought Lake Geneva could use a Panera Bread. We need a good bakery and I personally love their food. Make the lower level a Panera Bread - but preserve the historic nature of the structure and make the upper level rooms for rent or a shared office space like Regus/HQ does. I spoke with the owner several years ago to suggest partnering on this - he was going to get back to me but never did.

    Irv Segal
    Lake Geneva
  16. report print email
    Be careful!!
    December 21, 2010 | 07:27 PM

    many don't want to bring new business to the area. All that might do is bring in more tourists and revenue and many wouldn't that. It may upset this unique little town. Better to tear it down history than rehab it.

    Local Resident which one?
Walworth County Fair
Community Bank
Site Search

Pick up The Lake Geneva Regional News at these convenient locations
Community Bank
Lake Geneva Chiropractic
Tuesday
05 - 21 - 13
09:03
Search the Net