flag image
Chocolate Fest

Man faces charges after fatal crash



shadow
shadow
December 08, 2010 | 09:08 AM
Elkhorn — Jeremy C. Dees sat in an orange jail jumpsuit with a neck brace hunched at a table in an arraignment room in the Walworth County Correctional Center. He was visible only to those in court Friday via closed-circuit television.

With the Dorwin family watching in the courtroom, Dees was charged with homicide by negligent operation of a vehicle and two counts of reckless driving causing injury.

The charges are a result of a Nov. 16 crash that killed 9-year-old Eastview Elementary School student Carter Dorwin and injured his mother, Nicole, and brother, Bradley.

The court appearance lasted just a few minutes, with Judge Robert Kennedy reading the charges. Kennedy also informed a quiet Dees of his rights to obtain an attorney. Dees has been in Walworth County Jail since Sunday, Nov. 28, and is being held on a $250,000 bond. Dees is expected in court again on Dec. 10, at 1 p.m.

The homicide count is a felony and, if convicted, Dees may be fined not more than $25,000 or imprisoned not more than 10 years. The misdemeanor charges carry each between a $300 and $2,000 fine and between 30 days and a year in prison.

According to the complaint, Dees was on his way back to his home in Elkhorn after going to church in Lake Geneva that morning. It was about 7 a.m. and the Dorwins were on their way to school in Lake Geneva.

Dees' green Jeep was on Highway H leaving the city of Lake Geneva limits at an estimated 75 to 80 mph, according to a witness in the complaint. The witness also stated Dees' vehicle left the roadway onto the shoulder and then continued on Highway H.

Nicole Dorwin said Dees' vehicle was completely driving in her lane and was swerving. She said the oncoming vehicle was traveling west toward her and crossed the center line before swerving back. She said it crossed again and kept heading toward her.

At that time, Dorwin said she tried to move out of the way by pulling her vehicle off the roadway as far as she could and stopping. But, Dees struck the rear of Dorwin's vehicle, where Carter was sitting. The collision plunged the vehicles into the marsh off Highway H near Park Street.

Upon arrival at the accident, the police met with Nicole, who was with Bradley. According to the criminal complaint, she told police "her other son was in the vehicle still and that he was dead."

Dees told police after he went to the church, he was returning to Elkhorn, but he did not remember anything until he awoke in the hospital.

After the hearing was over, the Dorwin family and their friends met privately for about 15 minutes with Walworth County District Attorney Phil Koss. Following the hearing and meeting, Koss said he would not comment on the case.

Following the accident, police initially stated that "alcohol may have been a factor." However, a blood test after the crash showed there was no alcohol in Dees. Police say at the scene, Dees "blew a .03 percent" on the breath test and that "he had crossed over the center line at a high rate of speed" which typically are "good indicators" that alcohol may have been a factor. Results from a drug screen on Dees is still pending.

He has three prior drunken driving convictions, the last one being May 5, 2008. In 2009, he was convicted of a disorderly conduct charge in Marathon County. He also has ben found guilty of other alcohol- and drug-related charges and battery.

printPrint
emailEmail
CommentFeedback
shareShare
  1. report print email
    The story
    December 08, 2010 | 11:02 AM

    and the investigation continues. Now let things settle down with the comments until we hear the rest of the story by the Walworth County Sheriff's Department.

    ME
  2. report print email
    What a scumbag
    December 08, 2010 | 01:50 PM

    This idiot was convicted 3 TIMES for drunk driving, along with other crimes, which is at the crux of his incarceration. At #2 he should have been a convicted felon and put in prison for 10 years and PERMANENTLY lost his driving PRIVILEGES. Then this fool goes out and kills a little boy. Witnesses state they saw him driving 75-80 MPH, which on top of his record indicates complete irresponsibility.

    Wisconsin needs to changes its OWI laws so that repeat offenders are treated as felons, not misdemeanors, and they lose their licenses permanently. This guy should be locked up for 20 years at minimum. That little boy is gone forever.

    BHS '76er
    Somewhere outside of LG
  3. report print email
    WHY
    December 08, 2010 | 05:11 PM

    Why were all the previous comments deleted? None of the comments were vulgar or untrue. Just people looking for answers and stating the obvious. Freedom of speech? Ever hear of it?

    Disturbed
    Lake Geneva
  4. report print email
    BHS 76er
    December 08, 2010 | 06:52 PM

    What do you suggest we do with the county coroner who got a owi in walworth county driving the wrong way on the freeway. Does that make him a scumbag also big mouth. Hey also why don't you list your name I would love to see your rap sheet big shot.

    Spedos Sidekick
    LKG
  5. report print email
    Tragedy
    December 08, 2010 | 08:51 PM

    Loosing a child like this is a terrible tragedy. I cannot even fathem having to go through this. Yes indeed, this man should pay for his wrong doing. He probably should have paid for all of his previous wrong doings. But, for the sake of the Dorwin family, can't all of snide comments be kept to ourselves. It only hurts the family just that much more having to see all of this in the newspaper. The family has gone through so much already. Does the community really need to make it any harder for them. We can only hope that the good lord will give Mr. Dees the punishment that he deserves. This family deserves to have some peace in their lives.

    Bobbi Baker
    Lake Geneva
  6. report print email
    No comments deleted
    December 09, 2010 | 08:12 AM

    These comments are posted for each individual story. The comments I assume you are referring to are from the BREAKING story posted on Friday. This new story, which is from the newspaper and has some additional facts, took its place on the front page of the site. But, that BREAKING story should still be listed under the Lake Geneva tab, where all the comments remain.
    The Regional News never removes an entire post, just the portions that may be of concern. When removal occurs there is a (removed) placed where the words were removed.
    Of course, we are firm believers in the First Amendment as many who have wanted items removed in the past and I didn't take them off will attest.
    Thanks for reading.

    Lisa the Editor
    Lake Geneva
  7. report print email
    BHS '76er
    December 09, 2010 | 04:26 PM

    Well aren't we high and mighty? Avoid the mirror some more fool. HOW ABOUT....we rehabilitate at #1? Victim panels, AA and counseling for half a year cost a heck of a lot less than making someone a felon and permanently revoking their license, thereby inhibiting them from getting jobs and being productive citizens, locking them up for a year and sending them out with the same problems they came in with so they more than likely do it again.

    Yes, Wisconsin does need to change their OWI laws, but not in the shortsighted & ignorant way you describe.

    Common sense
    GC
  8. report print email
    RE: Common Sense
    December 09, 2010 | 05:24 PM

    How much more counseling do you think Mr. Dees needs? He has 3, count them 3 convictions involving Alcohol and this one pending. How much counseling would be sufficent for this guy? As for revoking his license permenaently I feel is proper. There are cabs to drive him to work, he has enough backers on this blog who could give him rides. Where is the line finally drawn and a person convicted of DUI pays for their offense? Lets hear your qualified response to WHERE WOULD THE LIMITS BE?

    Area Resident
  9. report print email
    RE: Common Sense
    December 09, 2010 | 07:28 PM

    With all due respect, you missed the point. If things had been handled properly from offense #1, offenses #2 & #3 might not have ever happened. Now here we are at offense #3,(and yes, I was able to count that high, thanks though), offense #1 & #2 were handled as they all typically are, fine, jail, probation la-de-da. Well rather than impeding his ability to function in society whenever it is that he actually does get reintroduced by making him a felon and permanently revoking his license, how about fixing the problem with the proper individual attention needed rather than just throwing punishments around. Should he be punished? Absolutely. He committed a crime and cost a life. Should he be rehabilitated in tandem? Again, absolutely. Unfortunately only the former question will be addressed and in 20 years or so when he gets out and he can't get a job or get himself to a job if he actually gets one, and all he's got left to do is sit around and drink, most likely get behind the wheel without a license anyway and someone else gets hurt, well, if we're both still around I'll try not to say I told you so.

    Common Sense
    GC
  10. report print email
    to area resident...
    December 09, 2010 | 07:30 PM

    You stated: " He has 3, count them 3 convictions involving Alcohol and this one pending." He may have three prior convictions in the past but there is no "this one pending". As other posters mentioned, let's hold the noise down until the investigation is completed.

    westender
  11. report print email
    My thoughts
    December 09, 2010 | 07:33 PM

    I think the problem that we face is the inability to understand what we or courts need to do to help these people. Instead at looking at what causes a person to do these things we simply put them in a place with no help and some how we expect them to walk out different human beings. I do believe that something causes you to be an addict. We just don't take the time to find it out. Now, he has had 3 prior convictions but when do things become repetative enough to look further. To treat this person so that he is able to live his life in a different way.

    Think
    lake geneva
  12. report print email
    RE: Think
    December 09, 2010 | 07:47 PM

    I understand what you are saying. But, when is enough counseling? You can counsel people til you turn blue and many will continue to repeat and repeat their offenses. That has been seen millions of times. Also, how much tax money needs to be spent on rehabilitation. Everyone including myself is taxed beyond the max. Now we take away a sex offenders rights to live where they want and work where they want because of their offenses. Why shouldn't the same be done for this type of offense? As for Common Sense's response about we shouldn't take a persons ability to work or get to work away. My question to him or her is. What type of punishment would be suitable for this type of repeat offender? He has been given numerous chances to seek and get help. It obviously hasn't worked and I am not including this offense because the final determination has not been made. So again let me ask Where do we stop holding their hands, boosting them up and they actually pay for their offense?

    Area Resident
  13. report print email
    Re: Westender
    December 09, 2010 | 08:03 PM

    I think you are absolutely right. Please lets hold the noise down until the investigation is complete. All this public "who ha" is just going to end up hurting the case. Don't the Dorwin's deserve there to be justice done. Please just everyoine stop the snide comments and let this family have some peace during this holiday season.

    Bobbi Baker
    Lake Geneva
  14. report print email
    My thoughts
    December 09, 2010 | 08:17 PM

    Has councling ever been tried? Has anyone ever really helped an alcoholic or drug addict besides what you see on intervention? I could see if it had been done or tried but the courts never do that. Why not just give it a chance and send him or another offender to rehablitation. as far as tax money look at what we spend to keep them in jail. money is being spend either way. what if and i do say what if on his second that someone had looked into the history and dug deep on the problem they would have seen and found someone that needed help. Someone whom may have responded well to it. I am sure you read his blog as i have and what you see is hurt, pain, and why did it stay that way? because nothing was done to help him along the way. He took a childs life and how horrible to this family. He has to live with that but instead of just putting him in jail give him the ability to have help, treatment, and an understanding. He has to live with this the rest of his life and he did what he did but i do not feel that just sending him to jail is the way to make it better. If you don't want someone to repeat a crime again look a little more deep into it.

    think
    lake geneva
  15. report print email
    The county
    December 09, 2010 | 08:26 PM

    has special blue busses to pick up the handicapped to let them be employed. Why can't there be a special buss that picks up offenders to take them to work; let's say into the city's commercial district? Of course they would have to pay for this privlage but hey; at least they get to work & it would be cheaper than a cab.
    Next I would like to see posted signs on the property that the individual lives at. This would indicate to the public that you have a OWI offender that shouldn't be driving & keep the public on alert. This should also be manditory for sex offenders. I know of a sex offender that owns a business on State Road 11 between East Sedgemeadow & County "F". I saw him with a young lady at a restraunt and really wanted to say something to her but by law you are not supposed to say anything - I don't know why but that's what I heard. If she had seen the sign in front of his red barn then she would have been better informed and safer.

    We need to be safe from them
  16. report print email
    RE: Common Sense
    December 09, 2010 | 08:26 PM

    How would you know if he's had ANY counseling? I would put a pretty high likelyhood, given some experience with this, that the answer is none. You've seen this "millioins" of times? Sorry I just don't buy it. We all know what happens with 1st offenses....bail, no jail and probation. 2nd offense, you do some time. 3rd offense, you do more time. I could go on and on. Nowhere is counseling part of the program. We complain about repeat offenses, tax dollars spent on jails, yet we're so content with "justice" being served, throwing them in a cell and permanently screwing up their lives so that they can never break the cycle that they were in that caused the problem in the first place. I'm glad you used "sex offender" as an example for comparison. You can't fix that. Someone doesn't give an adult man a potion that magically makes them want to molest a young boy. However, an alcohalic or drug addict can be changed. We just don't want to take the time to do that. It's too much work I guess. It's much easier to lock a problem away and hide it than confront it and actually address and fix it. I guess I'm not shocked at that sort of common, narrow thinking being expressed. If we would step out of the box a little bit and open our eyes, we might see that hey, if we do our best to fix Joe Alcoholic the first time around we might not have to pay for him to sit in jail 2 or 3 more times. We might transform him into a productive member of society rather than committing him to a marginalized life where he is left with no motivation to do anything or change anything about himself. It's not hand holding, it's having a more broad and open thought process on how to resolve a problem. What type of punishment is suitable for a repeat offender? I feel it would depend entirely on the offender. If this person had repeated 3 times maybe it's time to look a little deeper, not use blanket sentancing and hope the problem fixes itself by sitting on it for designated periods of time.

    Common Sense
    GC
  17. report print email
    RE: Common Sense GC, Think Lake Geneva
    December 09, 2010 | 09:12 PM

    Everyone talks about what it will cost to keep him in jail. Why not let him pay for his stay in jail? You know by working from jail. They use to call them chain gangs. He could also pay for his own therapy that way also. It would take care of his rehab and save the taxpayers also. I am all for giving people chances, but there comes a time you have to say it doesn't work. You know they say you can lead a horse to water but you can't make them drink. The same goes for this. We can offer assistance with counseling and treatment, but if they don't accept it we can't force them too. Here is a question no one has asked. Where was his family and friends during all this time he has needed help. Where were they? Now they speak out about his needing help because he faces a long time in jail if convicted. But before this tragedy where were they and why did they allow him to drive if he wasn't ready? Why didn't any of them intervene and drive him where he needed to go? Probably didn't want to be bothered. About 5 years ago I had to drive a person I worked with from the Huber dorm to work every morning. Because he was in there for repeat DUI. I had to get up every morning 2 hours earlier to go to Elkhorn, pick him up and take him to work. Then I went back home got ready and went to work myself. Many mornings in the snow and cold I would sit there at the Huber Dorm and wait for him. I would talk to the Sheriff's officers working there while I waited and they said many of those in there are repeat and repeat DUI offenders. Everyone of them said they were rehabbed and would never return. Yet they said it is like clock work that they return. So I took time out of my own life to help this guy and what happened he returned again because he couldn't keep from drinking. Even after counseling he still couldn't stay away from it. What do we do then? So, Let's just not blame his repeat offenses on the rest of society and the courts for failing him.

    Area Resident
  18. report print email
    RE: Bobbi Baker
    December 09, 2010 | 09:36 PM

    Your comment is appreciated but all this noise as you call it is nothing more than people commenting about a subject. It is called FREEDOM OF SPEECH. I do not believe what is commented on here is going to hinder this case. Everything disgussed here is public record and just people commenting on them and giving their thoughts about it.

    Area Resident
  19. report print email
    Area Resident
    December 10, 2010 | 06:41 AM

    SUCKER......

    MEEEEEEEE
  20. report print email
    RE: Sucker
    December 10, 2010 | 06:55 AM

    AH! another class comment. Then people wonder why this area is the way it is. It is loaded with juveniles in adult bodies. Itelligence starved, so when they have nothing to added legitimately to a discussion they make those kind of comments.

    Area Resident
  21. report print email
    Area Resident
    December 10, 2010 | 09:24 AM

    What school system failed you? Hurry to the curb as the short bus is honking the horn for you.

    MEEEEEEEEEEEE
  22. report print email
    Just 1 ?
    December 10, 2010 | 11:12 AM

    Why is it going back about 2 or 3 years ago a underage girl killed that mexican man on hwy H and we heard very little about her crime and also she got caught drinking while waiting for her trial. This girl was drunk and only got seven years in prison, so with saying that why is her case any diffrent than the J.Dees case they both happend in the same spot. The only driffrent is she was drunk and her was not.

    Now before you people jump all over me I do understand this is pending Drug test and also before you jump on the mexican band about this man SS # think before you talk because he was a citizen with the correct SS #'.

    Why
    LKG
  23. report print email
    Here's A Good One
    December 10, 2010 | 11:23 AM

    John Griebel county coroner back in 2006 was charged with driving the wrong way on hwy 43 along with driving drunk all info listed on wis cCap and you people sit here and say we need stronger laws on drunk drivers what would that matter when you have judges like CARLSEN letting guys like this of just because he's in county office that's a bunch of bullsh.t and if any of you think diffrent your sick people.

    Spedos Sidekick
    LKG
  24. report print email
    RE: Just 1
    December 10, 2010 | 12:02 PM

    Let's be brutally honest, the reason this story has gotten so much attention and drama is that a little boy died. If this was just another drunk driver story, no one would care. If this were a story of some 30 year old guy getting killed, no one would care. The story cited is a perfect example. I remember this happening, but I don't recall people having the same sense of outrage over it. This latest story was the perfect storm for the prohibition crowd, driver previously convicted, young child dies, what better story to champion their "cause" and let them get up on those soap boxes, preach about all the bad people, and let themselves feel superior to everyone else.

    Kinda reminds me of how all the news channels make a big deal out of the pretty blond white girl who goes "missing", but ignore all the "others" that go missing everyday....

    Enough Already
    Lake Geneva
  25. report print email
    RE: MEEEEEEEEEEEE
    December 10, 2010 | 12:33 PM

    You proved my point.

    Area Resident
  26. report print email
    Area Resident
    December 10, 2010 | 12:43 PM

    The only point you have is the point of your head. Mo Ron.

    Meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
  27. report print email
    Re: MEEEEEEEEEEEE
    December 10, 2010 | 04:30 PM

    You should be ashamed of yourself! Children or even adults that use "the little short bus" are human beings too. You obviously do not have a cognitively challenged child". You are the ignorant one!!!!!!!!!

    Parent of a cognitively challenged child
    Lake Geneva
  28. report print email
    RE:RE: MEEEEEEEE
    December 11, 2010 | 01:56 AM

    I believe the phrase "lighten up Francis" would be appropriate.

    Enough Already
    Lake Geneva
  29. report print email
    Dear Parent
    December 11, 2010 | 05:47 AM

    You are right I do not have any retarded kids.

    Meeeeeeeeee
  30. report print email
    Enough Already
    December 11, 2010 | 07:30 AM

    And as Red Foreman would say, " How would you like a foot up your ass, Dumbass?"

    Meeeeeeeeeee
Regional News
Walworth County Fair
Site Search

Pick up The Lake Geneva Regional News at these convenient locations
Lake Geneva Chiropractic
Community Bank
Monday
05 - 20 - 13
06:22
Search the Net